CAMEO-3D: Server Pairwise Comparison 6-months Performance (2021-10-22 - 2022-04-16)

The pairwise comparison is showing the average differences of the reference with all the other servers, each on a common data subset. It is misleading to compare further servers among each other, without selecting a new reference as for each server pair the common subset may differ. Numbers in green denote scores where the reference server is better, numbers in red where another server was outperforming the reference server.

Server Name
Targets
modeled
Oligo-Targets
modeled
Avg. Response Time
(hh:mm:ss)
Avg.
lDDT
Avg.
CAD-score
Avg.
lDDT-BS
Avg.
QS-score
Avg.
MM-align
Dif. Com. Dif. Com. Dif. Ref Dif. Ref. Dif. Ref. Dif. Ref. Dif. Ref. Dif. Ref.
PRIMO - Reference
Naive AlphaFoldDB 100 163 55 0 0 --3:28:07 02:32:26 -31.62 51.13 -25.97 52.89 -32.51 46.12 - - - - server100 True
PaFold -78 204 0 0 -66:28:19 03:06:15 -19.09 55.16 -15.91 56.40 -16.38 51.09 - - - - server101 False
Robetta -50 189 0 0 -08:45:21 02:59:53 -17.30 55.24 -14.75 56.50 -14.06 50.64 - - - - server11 False
Phyre2 -133 237 0 0 --2:14:12 03:06:35 -0.43 54.34 -0.35 55.77 -4.83 49.50 - - - - server17 False
RoseTTAFold -128 232 0 0 -09:08:04 03:02:28 -19.44 54.15 -16.30 55.67 -13.74 51.09 - - - - server19 False
SWISS-MODEL -135 239 0 0 --3:02:13 03:03:27 -8.63 54.38 -6.25 55.81 -8.27 50.00 - - - - server20 False
RaptorX 56 118 0 0 -07:09:36 03:08:14 -12.22 53.93 -10.79 55.67 -11.17 48.02 - - - - server22 False
SPARKS-X 241 0 0 0 - - - - - - - - - - - - server30 True
IntFOLD3-TS -93 224 0 0 -35:58:27 03:02:19 -9.86 53.85 -8.36 55.36 -10.40 51.07 - - - - server33 False
NaiveBLAST -79 203 0 0 --4:55:37 03:05:08 1.83 56.53 3.68 57.11 -0.90 50.04 - - - - server36 False
IntFOLD4-TS -80 218 0 0 -52:15:40 03:00:19 -12.03 54.06 -10.22 55.57 -12.61 50.74 - - - - server58 False
PRIMO_BST_3D 49 179 0 0 -00:14:09 02:53:56 3.05 51.98 2.72 53.99 1.71 44.96 - - - - server62 False
PRIMO_HHS_3D 174 58 0 0 -00:58:32 02:13:07 1.36 44.70 1.68 49.36 -5.90 49.54 - - - - server63 True
PRIMO_HHS_CL 162 64 0 0 -01:13:31 02:01:25 -6.51 44.05 -4.98 49.25 -7.40 48.29 - - - - server64 True
PRIMO_BST_CL 14 204 0 0 --1:59:16 02:57:29 0.00 53.11 0.00 54.90 0.00 48.05 - - - - server65 False
IntFOLD5-TS -66 209 0 0 -28:53:28 03:02:04 -12.17 54.33 -10.65 55.72 -12.68 50.39 - - - - server75 False
IntFOLD6-TS -97 228 0 0 -26:02:04 03:01:37 -13.38 53.82 -11.17 55.43 -14.60 50.61 - - - - server90 False
pureAF2_orig -130 235 0 0 -33:56:59 03:06:17 -31.86 54.23 -25.98 55.74 -27.81 50.46 - - - - server96 False
pureAF2_notemp -134 240 0 0 -39:16:20 03:05:43 -31.36 54.27 -25.77 55.72 -27.47 50.42 - - - - server97 False
ZlxFold -105 214 0 0 -60:17:52 03:05:14 -29.48 55.05 -23.90 56.43 -26.51 51.39 - - - - server98 False
BestSingleStructuralTemplate -112 228 0 0 -00:51:13 03:01:08 -16.58 54.22 -13.75 55.73 -15.69 50.36 - - - - server999 False
Naive AlphaFoldDB 90 125 81 0 0 --3:09:14 02:51:13 -26.65 54.28 -21.78 55.25 -28.83 48.12 - - - - server99 False
Target
ref. PDB lDDT CAD-score lDDT-BS QS-score MM-align Difficulty
Diff Ref Best Diff Ref Best Diff Ref Best Diff Ref Best Diff Ref Best